FEMA Explained (Part 5): Penalties, Compounding, Appeals and the Complete Compliance Calendar
FEMA Section 13 penalties, late submission fee, compounding under Section 15, the appeal ladder, director liability and a complete FEMA compliance calendar.
Illustration: a company realises in October that its FC-GPR for a March allotment was never filed. Does it face a penalty of three times the investment, a small late fee, or something in between? The answer depends on what went wrong, and how quickly the company fixes it.
- Part 1: What FEMA is, who it covers, the rule book
- Part 2: Money coming in: FDI, FC-GPR, FC-TRS, FLA
- Part 3: Money going out: LRS, ODI, ECB
- Part 4: Trade and people: exports, imports, NRIs
- Part 5: Penalties, compounding, appeals, calendar (you are here)
1. What Section 13 actually says
| Situation | Maximum exposure under Section 13(1) |
|---|---|
| Amount involved can be quantified | Up to three times the sum involved |
| Amount cannot be quantified | Up to Rs 2 lakh |
| Contravention continues | Further penalty up to Rs 5,000 for every day after the first day |
| Section 13(2) | Adjudicating authority may direct confiscation of currency, security or property equal to the amount involved |
Who is liable? Under Section 42, where a company contravenes FEMA, every person in charge of and responsible for its business at the time is deemed guilty, unless they prove the contravention occurred without their knowledge or that they exercised all due diligence. Directors and finance heads should read this as a personal-exposure rule.
2. Three ways a lapse can be resolved
| Route | Best for | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Late Submission Fee | Delayed reporting (FC-GPR, FC-TRS, FLA, APR, Form FC) | AD bank accepts the late filing with LSF; no adjudication |
| Compounding (Section 15) | Substantive or larger contraventions, and delays outside the LSF route | Voluntary application to the RBI (or the Directorate of Enforcement for Section 3(a)); a compounding order is passed on payment |
| Adjudication and appeal | Disputed or serious matters | Show cause notice, adjudication order, then the appeal ladder |
3. Compounding, step by step
Compounding is governed by the Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2024 (G.S.R. 566(E), 12 September 2024) and the RBI Master Direction on Compounding of Contraventions (No. 04/2025-26, 22 April 2025). The RBI compounds contraventions under Section 13 other than those under Section 3(a), which are compounded by the Director of Enforcement.
Not compoundable by the RBI: Section 3(a) contraventions, cases where the amount is not quantifiable, cases under Section 37A, cases where an adjudicating authority has already passed a penalty order, and contraventions the compounding authority considers to need further investigation by the Directorate of Enforcement.
4. Adjudication and the appeal ladder
Civil imprisonment: Section 14 allows enforcement of penalty orders and, in specified cases of non-payment, civil imprisonment (the period depends on the penalty amount; confirm).
5. The master FEMA compliance calendar
| What | When | Where / form |
|---|---|---|
| Allot shares after receiving foreign funds | Within 60 days of receipt; else refund within 15 days | Company records; AD bank |
| Report share issue to non-resident | 30 days from allotment | FC-GPR on FIRMS |
| Report transfer resident / non-resident | 60 days | FC-TRS on FIRMS |
| Downstream investment | 30 days from allotment | Form DI |
| Annual Return on Foreign Liabilities and Assets | 15 July every year | FLA via FLAIR |
| Overseas investment | Before or at remittance, whichever is earlier | Form FC through AD bank |
| Annual Performance Report | 31 December every year | APR, per foreign entity |
| Disinvestment / restructuring abroad | 30 days (confirm) | Form FC |
| ECB drawdown or repayment | Within 7 calendar days of month-end | Form ECB-2 |
| Export proceeds | 9 months from shipment or invoice (12 for rupee exports) | Via AD bank; EDF |
| LRS remittance | At remittance | Form A2 |
| Adjudication appeal | 45 days (Special Director), 45 days (Tribunal), 60 days (High Court) | Section 17, 19, 35 |
6. Ten mistakes that turn a small lapse into a penalty case
- Waiting for a notice before filing a late return.
- Not documenting the cause of delay.
- Ignoring the director-level exposure under Section 42.
- Paying LSF repeatedly without fixing the process.
- Treating a substantive breach (wrong route, wrong pricing, prohibited sector) as a reporting delay.
- Replying to a show cause notice without the underlying documents.
- Missing the 45-day appeal clock.
- Filing compounding with incomplete details of the transaction.
- Assuming the bank has already reported everything.
- Following pre-2026 procedures for ECB or export-import after the rule changes.
7. FEMA health check: 12 questions to answer today
| # | Question | Yes / No |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Is every foreign remittance received or sent through an authorised bank? | |
| 2 | Have all share allotments to non-residents been reported within 30 days? | |
| 3 | Do we hold fair value certificates for foreign issues and transfers? | |
| 4 | Were all resident / non-resident transfers reported in FC-TRS? | |
| 5 | Is the FLA return filed every year by 15 July? | |
| 6 | Is every overseas investment backed by Form FC, UIN and a timely APR? | |
| 7 | Is the 400% net worth limit tested on the latest audited balance sheet? | |
| 8 | Is the ECB documentation aligned to the February 2026 rules? | |
| 9 | Do we track export realisation dates against the 9-month period? | |
| 10 | Do directors know their Section 42 exposure? | |
| 11 | Do family members track their USD 250,000 LRS usage and TCS? | |
| 12 | Do we have a written FEMA calendar with a named owner? |
Why work with ComplianceKart
ComplianceKart is a boutique practice bringing Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries and advocates under one roof. Think of a multi-speciality hospital: the physician, the radiologist and the pharmacist read from one patient file, so you never carry reports between buildings. A FEMA lapse is rarely only a FEMA issue: it can touch the company file, tax treatment and a contract. When the people who understand each angle work together, regularisation is faster and the story told to the regulator is consistent.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the maximum penalty for a FEMA contravention?
Up to three times the sum involved where quantifiable, or up to Rs 2 lakh where it is not, with up to Rs 5,000 per day for continuing contraventions, as per Section 13.
Is late FEMA filing always penalised?
Delays in reporting are generally regularised through a Late Submission Fee. Larger or substantive contraventions may require compounding or adjudication.
What is compounding under FEMA?
A voluntary route under Section 15 where the contravener applies and pays a compounding amount, resulting in a compounding order instead of adjudication.
Where do I appeal against an adjudication order?
To the Special Director (Appeals) or the Appellate Tribunal within 45 days, and then to the High Court within 60 days on a question of law.
Can directors be personally liable?
Yes. Under Section 42, persons in charge of and responsible for a company’s business can be held liable unless they prove lack of knowledge or due diligence.
Sources
- FEMA, 1999: Sections 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, 35, 37A and 42
- Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2024 (G.S.R. 566(E), 12 September 2024)
- RBI Master Direction No. 04/2025-26 on Compounding of Contraventions (22 April 2025)
- RBI Master Direction on Reporting under FEMA, 1999
Website: FEMA and NRI compliance services
Email: team@compliancekart.com
Phone: 9959536391
Educational article, last updated 11 November 2026. It is general information, not advice on a specific transaction. FEMA directions change often; confirm the position on the date you act. Items marked (confirm) were reported by secondary sources and should be checked against the RBI or Gazette text.
Need this done for your business?
Send us one message. A CA, CS or Advocate replies within a working day — no forms, no obligation.